Reviewing Resources

When I review a paper I find it helpful to have a checklist of what belongs in a good scientific review, so I don't forget anything. I've put my checklist on the web. My hope is that you will find it helpful.

If you are reviewing an IEEE Transactions on Neural Networks paper for me, I have a page for online reviews.

For IEEE TNN review forms in postscript or ASCII, see Lee Giles' page for reviewers.

For a definitive source on thoughtful reviewing, see Ian Parberry's Referee's Guide.

Barak Pearlmutter <barak@pearlmutter.net>